Back to Blog
by Kronux Team time-tracking

Manual vs. Automatic Time Tracking: Which Is Right for You?

Time tracking falls into two camps: manual (you start and stop timers) and automatic (software records in the background). Each has tradeoffs. Here’s how they compare so you can pick what fits your workflow.

Manual Time Tracking

How it works: You start a timer when you begin a task and stop it when you finish. Some tools let you add notes or categories per block.

Pros:

  • Simple—no special permissions, no background monitoring
  • You control what gets logged
  • Works offline, no sync required
  • Often cheaper or free

Cons:

  • Easy to forget—gaps and inaccuracies are common
  • Interrupts flow when you switch tasks
  • Relies on memory and honesty
  • Doesn’t capture context switches or micro-interruptions

Best for: People who work in long, discrete blocks and don’t mind the discipline of logging.

Automatic Time Tracking

How it works: An app monitors which applications and windows you use, plus duration. Some detect meetings, breaks, and idle time. You review and categorize later—or let AI suggest categories.

Pros:

  • Accurate—captures reality, not your best guess
  • Zero effort during the day—no timers to manage
  • Reveals patterns you’d miss (e.g., 30 min of scattered Slack)
  • Works with AI for smart categorization

Cons:

  • Needs permission to monitor activity
  • Privacy concern if data goes to the cloud
  • Can feel invasive until you trust the tool
  • May require a Mac-specific app

Best for: People who want honest data without the overhead, and who are okay with local-only or privacy-respecting tools.

Privacy: The Critical Difference

Manual trackers rarely send data anywhere—you type what you want. Automatic trackers see your activity. Where that data goes matters:

  • Cloud automatic — Logs sync to servers. Check the privacy policy.
  • Local automatic — Everything stays on your Mac. No uploads. The only way to get automatic capture with full privacy.

If you’re considering automatic tracking, local-first is the default for anyone handling sensitive work.

Hybrid Approaches

Some people use both: automatic capture for the raw log, manual tagging for projects or clients. Or automatic for awareness, manual timers only for billable work. The right mix depends on your needs.

Bottom Line

Manual works if you’re disciplined and don’t mind the friction. Automatic works if you want accuracy and low effort—just choose a tool that keeps your data local. For most people who’ve tried both, automatic wins once privacy is assured.